CCTV Plagiarizes Japanese Cartoon

| September 2nd, 2009

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-29 20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-30

[Sina] Just when the Chinese original cartoon “Pleasant Goat and Big Big Wolf” being praised and awarded, CCTV children’s channel started showing another “original made” cartoon “Window of Sprits” (that’s how I translate the name(“心灵之窗”), but was criticized for plagiarizing! Netizens posted posts with the titles like “Being a man cannot be like CCTV” on forums accusing “Window of Sprits” plagiarized a famous Japanese Cartoon “5 Centimeters per Second”.

Whether the is character model, or the background scenery, they are 90% similar! Netizens sighs in unison “It is hopeless, Chinese Cartoon plagiarizes to this extend…” The maker of this cartoon Lanhai Technology spokesman refuses to be interviewed. CCTV says they know nothing about this at all.

August 22nd, “Window of Sprits” started showing CCTV children’s channel. The Story is heartwarming and interesting and also talks about last year’s Wenchuan earthquake, viewing rating is no less than “Pleasant Goat and Big Big Wolf”. However netizens recently pointed out this cartoon is extremely similar to the famous Japanese cartoon “5 Centimeters per Second”. Pictures from both cartoons were posted for comparison.

See them for yourself, from the panoramic view of the city to character’s posture, hairstyle, clothing and even one of the main character are almost exactly the same between the two films. This cartoon is supposed to teach children about morality, “but the maker of the cartoon did not even have the basic ethical values, how do you teach kids to be honest?”

 20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-01

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-02

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-03

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-04

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-05

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-06

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-07

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-08

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-09

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-10

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-12

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-11  20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-13

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-14

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-15

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-16

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-17

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-18

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-19

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-20

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-21

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-22

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-23

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-24

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-25

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-26

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-27

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-28

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-29

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-30

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-31

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-32

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-33

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-34

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-35

Pictures from Cantonese Comic Community

———-

This is not the first time CCTV was accused of plagiarizing Japanese cartoon. July of this year Netizens already exposed “China made” cartoon “Big Mouth Dudu” (大嘴巴嘟嘟) being a copy of famous Japanese Cartoon “Crayon Shin-chan
 20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-36

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-37

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-38

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-39

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-40

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-41

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-42

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-43

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-44

20090902-plagiarizing-cartoon-45

Experts say reason for plagiarizing is to cut cost.  If the plot is different, but characters and backgrounds are changed and modified then it is not plagiarizing.  With over all similarity over 70% is definitely plagiarizing.

What do you think just base on the pictures posted above?

6 Comments | Leave a comment | Comment feed

  1. jay says:

    Poor excuses from a lazy story board designer

    At least they didn’t copy everything, looks like progress

  2. xmq_jpm says:

    I love how they think it might be bad to knock off cartoons, but when it comes to obtaining by all means advanced Western technology then it doesn’t get reported and is rather generally approved of. Talk about focusing attention where it doesn’t matter!

  3. JOHN ARM says:

    How about the transformers copies!!!

  4. Jianfeng says:

    Happy Sheep and Gray Wolf is great!

    Another Chinese-made cartoon, which I would recommend and don’t think is plagiarizing anything Japanese, is Red Cat and Blue Rabbit.

  5. Colin says:

    If you look closely, You can see the Chinese animators had used the same exact images as 5 CM per second. But just blurred areas of the background and alter some colours.

    Wow this is really pathetic.

  6. Nice level of information here. There is so much information around about this issue that from time to time you cannot see the wood for the trees but you have pitched this at entirely the correct level so that the lay person can comprehend – thank you!

Leave a Comment


four × 1 =

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Hao Hao Report
  2. 3DGuy website » Blog Archive » Check this out! Charming 3D Cartoon Faces
Kepard - Premium VPN Service

Latest Posts

Too shy to share your umbrella? Show it

Annie Lee | September 16th, 2014
54111323f1993

China’s Guinness world record complex

Annie Lee | September 13th, 2014
900x600_A5LT8E0E5LP10001

Recent Comments

How to turn real egg into 'Fake' egg? Easy, buy any real eggs and keep it for longer then 3 weeks. …» more

The producers shoud be arrested and jail for cheating » more

It is great to remember 6/4 because this work of the greatest man of the China whom I always respect. …» more

Although she may feel alone now, I'm sure she's going to be well-educated by the end of the school. One-on-one …» more

China sucks that's why they leave. It's not really about corruption. It's about having access to enough cash to leave …» more

Subscribe by email

Enter your email address: